EDS & hypermobility guide

Hypermobility Spectrum Disorder (HSD): How It Differs From hEDS

Hypermobility spectrum disorder (HSD) describes people whose hypermobile joints cause real problems — pain, instability, injuries, fatigue — but who don't meet the strict criteria for hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome. It was introduced in 2017 to replace older terms like joint hypermobility syndrome, and it is far from a minor diagnosis.

AZ Physiotherapy Limited · Updated

On this page
  1. Hypermobility is common — the disorder is not
  2. Where HSD sits on the spectrum
  3. The four types of HSD
  4. HSD vs hEDS: what is the difference?
  5. Symptoms of HSD
  6. Why the label matters less than you might think
  7. How physiotherapy helps HSD
  8. References

Hypermobility is common — the disorder is not

Being flexible is common, especially in children, women and people of some ethnic backgrounds, and it naturally reduces with age. Many people with very mobile joints never have a problem with them. Dancers, gymnasts and musicians can even benefit from it.

Joint hypermobility only becomes a disorder when it comes with symptoms — usually pain, instability, recurrent injuries or fatigue — that affect daily life. That is the key idea behind the 2017 framework: hypermobility sits on a spectrum, from no symptoms at all through to hypermobile EDS.

Where HSD sits on the spectrum

The 2017 framework separates hypermobility that causes no problems from hypermobility that does:

Without symptoms (not a disorder)With symptoms
Generalised joint hypermobility (GJH)Generalised HSD, or hEDS if all criteria are met
Peripheral joint hypermobility (hands and feet)Peripheral HSD
Localised joint hypermobility (one joint or a few)Localised HSD
—Historical HSD (hypermobile in the past)

The four types of HSD

  • Generalised HSD (G-HSD) — hypermobility across many joints (a positive Beighton score), with musculoskeletal symptoms, but not meeting every hEDS criterion.
  • Peripheral HSD (P-HSD) — hypermobility mainly in the hands and feet, with symptoms.
  • Localised HSD (L-HSD) — hypermobility in a single joint or group of joints, with symptoms. A shoulder that repeatedly subluxes is a common example.
  • Historical HSD (H-HSD) — people who were clearly hypermobile when younger (often confirmed on the five-point questionnaire) but now score lower, as joints stiffen with age, and still have symptoms.

HSD vs hEDS: what is the difference?

The difference is in the diagnostic criteria, not necessarily in how much you suffer.

To be diagnosed with hypermobile EDS, you must meet all three 2017 criteria: generalised hypermobility, enough additional body-wide features or family history or musculoskeletal complications, and other conditions ruled out. If you have symptomatic hypermobility but fall short on any part of that — for example, you don't have enough of the listed skin and tissue features — the diagnosis is usually HSD.

The 2017 authors were clear that HSD is not intended to be a less severe condition. Many people with HSD have pain, instability and fatigue that are just as significant as in hEDS. Some people's diagnosis also changes over time as more features become apparent.

Symptoms of HSD

Symptoms overlap closely with hEDS:

  • Joint pain, often in several joints and often worse after activity
  • Joints that feel unstable, give way, or sublux
  • Frequent sprains, strains and soft tissue injuries
  • Reduced proprioception — a poorer sense of joint position — and clumsiness
  • Fatigue and reduced exercise tolerance
  • In some people, symptoms in other systems such as dizziness on standing or gut problems

Why the label matters less than you might think

From a physiotherapy point of view, treatment is guided by what is actually happening in your body: which joints are unstable, which muscles are weak, how your pain behaves, how much load you can currently tolerate, and what you want to get back to. Two people with the same diagnosis can need very different programmes, and two people with different labels can need very similar ones.

So, whether your diagnosis is HSD, hEDS or still unclear, you can start rehabilitation now. A diagnosis is still worth pursuing through your GP, because it can help with understanding, family history and access to other care.

How physiotherapy helps HSD

The approach mirrors hEDS care, and is described in more depth in our rehabilitation guide:

  1. A thorough assessment of joint range, stability, strength, balance and how symptoms behave
  2. Education, so you understand what's driving your symptoms and can make good decisions day to day
  3. Progressive strengthening of the muscles that support your problem joints, and of the whole body
  4. Control and proprioception training, so joints are supported through their range
  5. Pacing, to build capacity without the boom-and-bust cycle of flare-ups
  6. A flare-up plan, so setbacks are shorter and less frightening

References

  1. Castori M, Tinkle B, Levy H, et al. A framework for the classification of joint hypermobility and related conditions. Am J Med Genet C Semin Med Genet. 2017;175(1).
  2. Malfait F, Francomano C, Byers P, et al. The 2017 international classification of the Ehlers–Danlos syndromes. Am J Med Genet C Semin Med Genet. 2017;175(1).
  3. Engelbert RHH, Juul-Kristensen B, Pacey V, et al. The evidence-based rationale for physical therapy treatment of children, adolescents, and adults diagnosed with joint hypermobility syndrome/hypermobile Ehlers–Danlos syndrome. Am J Med Genet C Semin Med Genet. 2017;175(1).

Frequently asked questions

Is HSD less serious than hEDS?
Not necessarily. The difference is in the diagnostic criteria, not severity. The 2017 framework states that HSD can be just as painful and disabling as hEDS, and the physiotherapy approach is very similar.
Can HSD turn into hEDS?
HSD doesn't 'turn into' hEDS, but a diagnosis can be revised as more features become apparent or are recognised, or when a family member is diagnosed. Your GP or specialist can review this over time.
Is joint hypermobility syndrome the same as HSD?
Largely, yes. 'Joint hypermobility syndrome' (JHS) was an older term. Since 2017, most people previously diagnosed with JHS are described as having either HSD or hEDS, depending on whether they meet the hEDS criteria.
Do I need a diagnosis of HSD to see a physio?
No. You can book directly with a physiotherapist in New Zealand without a GP referral or a formal diagnosis. Treatment is based on your assessment findings and goals.
Abdullah Abdullah

Your EDS & hypermobility physiotherapist

Abdullah Abdullah — Physiotherapist & Founder, AZ Physiotherapy Limited

Abdullah has a special clinical interest in EDS, hEDS, HSD and symptomatic joint hypermobility. He also has lived experience with EDS and hypermobility, alongside ongoing professional development in this area. Meet Abdullah

This guide is general information and isn’t a substitute for an individual assessment or medical advice. If you have severe, worsening or unusual symptoms, seek medical advice promptly.

More EDS & hypermobility guides

Build joints you can trust

Hypermobility-informed physiotherapy in Pakuranga and at Waitakere Health Hub, Henderson.